Gilt Chambers Barrister Phillip Ross Unworthy - Said Court of Appeal​ in HKSAR v Apelete (No 2) [2019] 5 HKLRD 602 [2019] HKCA 1320 (per ​Macrae VP​ at para 58)​

Gilt Chambers Barrister Phillip Ross Unworthy - Said Court of Appeal​ in HKSAR v Apelete (No 2) [2019] 5 HKLRD 602 [2019] HKCA 1320 (per ​Macrae VP​ at para 58)​ 


"S​uch an answer, for which Mr Ross took no instructions before uttering it, was unworthy of any advocate appearing before the Court of Appeal and was as fanciful and devoid of common sense as the ground of appeal itself.​" - per ​Macrae VP​ at para 58.​

Mr Phillip Ross, instructed by K B Chau & Co, assigned by the Director of Legal Aid, for the Applicant

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

鍾元富大律師 (Barrister Hylas Chung) 被法官狠批「做法不專業，損人不利己」(Unprofessional, Harmed Others And Did Not Benefit Self)

鍾元富大律師 (Barrister Hylas Chung) 被法官狠批「做法不專業，損人不利己」(Unprofessional, Harmed Others And Did Not Benefit Self) https://joycekwan20130602.blogspot.com/2014/01/lawyer-hylas-chung-counsel-barrister-unprofessional.html 香港特別行政區 訴 袁郁鈞 (Reported in: [2007] 1 HKLRD 819) HCMA730/2006 (裁判日期：2007年1月23日) https://legalref.judiciary.hk/lrs/common/search/search_result_detail_frame.jsp?DIS=55815&QS=%2B&TP=JU 「上訴人的大律師鍾元富大律師 (Barrister Hylas Chung) 本身對刑事審訊接納證據的基本法則一知半解，胡亂指控聆訊時代表上訴人的大律師不稱職，不切實際地提昇上訴人對成功上訴的期望、做法不專業，損人不利己 (Unprofessional, Harmed Others And Did Not Benefit Self)，絕對不值得鼓勵或仿效 (Utterly Should Never Be Encouraged Or Imitated。」 - 高等法院原訟法庭暫委法官潘敏琦 (Deputy High Court Judge Maggie Poon)
Read more

Milton Lai Fabricated Evidence in Court - Said DDJ George Lam - LAI KO CHOY v LAI KIN (黎健) & KWONG LAI SIM (鄺麗嬋)

Milton Lai Fabricated Evidence in Court - Said DDJ George Lam  DCCJ 1917/2018 [2021] HKDC 378 LAI KO CHOY v LAI KIN (黎健) & KWONG LAI SIM (鄺麗嬋) 90. I find that Milton Lai was fabricating his evidence in court. It seems to me that Milton Lai was trying to salvage the weakness in the plaintiff’s case where the plaintiff cared nothing about the mortgage. I reject Milton Lai’s evidence entirely in relation to the purchase of the Property or any discussion about the mortgage. I did not believe a financial consultant could have advised his father when acquiring a property without any of the above-mentioned essential information. https://unreasonablelitigants.blogspot.com/2021/04/milton-lai-fabricated-evidence-in-court-said-ddj-george-lam.html
Read more

Barrister Kerby Lau of Des Voeux Chambers (DVC) “unhelpful”, says [2018] HKCA 403 (Cheung, Yuen and Kwan JJA)

Barrister Kerby Lau of Des Voeux Chambers (DVC) “unhelpful”, says [2018] HKCA 403 (Cheung, Yuen and Kwan JJA) 8.   The defendant’s counsel cited a total of 38 cases in this application .  As stated in Practice Direction 2.1 §3(e), the skeleton submissions “should direct at helping the Court to determine whether grounds have been made out for the appeal to be heard by the Court of Final Appeal”.   It is unhelpful to load the submissions with copious authorities making more or less the same point in a number of instances . Written submissions by Barristers Mr Chua Guan Hock SC and Mr Kerby Lau, instructed by K B Chau & Co Solicitors, for the Defendant (Applicant) https://legalref.judiciary.hk/lrs/common/ju/ju_frame.jsp?DIS=116701&currpage=T http://gettingjusticeinhongkong.blogspot.com/2019/05/barrister-chua-guan-hock-sc-and-barrister-kerby-lau-unhelpful-says-the-hong-kong-court-of-appeal.html
Read more